Oil based polyurethane over water based. Theres an ongoing debate over which is more durable long lasting. Remove all sanding dust. Both water based and oil based poly offer good protection. When using an oil based topcoat over a water based stain or milk paint allow water based finishes such as hp topcoat to dry at least 24 hours before coating with an oil based product.
Recoating a water based acrylic floor finish with oil based polyurethane is not usually a problem so long as the old finish is properly buffed and cleaned before applying the new finish. This is because the curing process for oil is polymerisation and polymerised oil is akin to resin. Surface must be dry and free of old finishes in poor condition paint wax grease polish dirt or other foreign matter. Do not use them over white or very light colors.
Durability of water based vs oil based polyurethane. Oil based used to be unquestionably more durable. Do not use steel wool. However oil based varnishes typically have a natural amber tint and often become more yellow over time.
They appear milky in the can but go on clear and remain clear. Oil based over water based when using an oil based topcoat over a water based stain or milk paint allow water based finishes such as hp topcoat to dry at least 24 hours before coating with an oil based product other tips oil based finishes amber over time. If possible it is always best to use an acrylic based varnish for water based paints and oil based varnish for oil based paints to ensure good results. If you already laid down a water based finish and decided to go for an oil based one do not fret.
If you wait for the oil based stain to properly dry cure its no longer oily. Some still insist that durability is the main deciding factor between water based oil based polyurethane. Luckily there are ways around this when it comes to applying finishes. If you love the natural look of maple apply a water based waterborne polyurethane.
Its actually the most durable hardwood floor finish. With a little bit of extra time and preparation you can apply the oil based finish right over the water. Sand to obtain a smooth uniform surface. The biggest difference is in appearance.